The Stranger quipped, "The gays know how to have fun: They know it, you know it, I know it, and Pony is more fun per inch than anywhere in town, if not the world. Oh, and there's a gloryhole in the bathroom, if that's your thing. In 2013, Seattle overtook San Francisco as the. Drinks are affordable and (pun intended) stiff, and I'm led to believe that it still serves as one of the city's better meat markets. Seattles gay shopping and recreation area is centered on Capitol Hill with bars, bookstores and other venues. Because it doesn't pander to a straight crowd, it remains relevant to several generations of gay guys in Seattle without going too far down the nightclub rabbit hole. If you were unsure of this upon entering, the gay pornography plastered on almost every inch of the space will reassure you very quickly that you are in fact in a gay bar. While other Capitol Hill bars try to appeal to both a gay and straight clientele, Pony is unabashedly aimed at gay males.
Let's be blatantly clear: Pony is not a bar for those who only dabble in gay culture. The paper's Zach Geballe said of the bar and its clientele: In 2013, Seattle Weekly readers voted for Pony as the best gay bar in Seattle. This isn't a zoo and we're not your pets." Reception If you aren't queer (or a respectful ally), get lost.
In 2014, in response to the neighborhood's changing demographics, the bar's manager displayed a sign which read, "Attention: This is a gay bar. Seattle Weekly described Pony as a "one-of-a-kind bar that pays tribute to New York's Castro and West Village bars of the 1970s". It is housed in a 1930s building that served as a gas station. Pony is located at 1221 E Madison Street in Seattle's Capitol Hill neighborhood.